ScyllaDB University LIVE, FREE Virtual Training Event | March 21
Register for Free
ScyllaDB Documentation Logo Documentation
  • Server
    • ScyllaDB Open Source
    • ScyllaDB Enterprise
    • ScyllaDB Alternator
  • Cloud
  • Tools
    • ScyllaDB Manager
    • ScyllaDB Monitoring Stack
    • ScyllaDB Operator
  • Drivers
    • CQL Drivers
    • DynamoDB Drivers
Download
Menu
ScyllaDB Docs ScyllaDB Open Source Troubleshooting Scylla Data Storage and SSTables There Are A Lot Of Single SSTable Compactions That Don’t Compact Anything

There Are A Lot Of Single SSTable Compactions That Don’t Compact Anything¶

This guide describes what to do if you start having many tombstones compactions that don’t compact anything.

Phenomena¶

Scylla’s CPU utilization is unexpectedly high and we see too many compactions while there are not many WRITE/UPDATE/DELETE/TTLed operations and you see many messages like this in the syslog:

compaction - Compacted 1 SSTables to ... (~100% of original) ...

Problem¶

Scylla SSTables can have expired or soon to be expired tombstones in them and there is a need to clean them up eventually. Tombstones can be generated by DELETE operations, TTL data, insertion of null fields or usage of collections. Compactions will get rid of expired tombstones, but if there are no compactions currently happening, Scylla may apply heuristics to force compactions on a lone table that has a certain ratio of expired tombstones.

To validate that the SSTable being compacted indeed has tombstones:

sstablemetadata /var/lib/scylla/data/some_ks/some_cf-UUID/some_ks-ka-*-Data.db | grep "Estimated droppable tombstones:"

The output may be something like this:

Estimated droppable tombstones: 0.08672144669324656
Estimated droppable tombstones: 0.08935147496746765
Estimated droppable tombstones: 0.11850671228977766
Estimated droppable tombstones: 0.08511697234511045
Estimated droppable tombstones: 0.035764466964587543
Estimated droppable tombstones: 0.1894537114259597
Estimated droppable tombstones: 0.13213090183839682
Estimated droppable tombstones: 0.1208004932191389
Estimated droppable tombstones: 0.07019800509981686
Estimated droppable tombstones: 0.12196540423823726
Estimated droppable tombstones: 0.11981627152867445
Estimated droppable tombstones: 0.11780386543765468
Estimated droppable tombstones: 0.17214256718348064

Heuristics is not a perfect solution and it may issue a compaction in cases where there are no expired tombstones to drop. Should this happen, a tombstone compaction may begin needlessly, wasting CPU and I/O resources resulting in a compacted table which shows no change from the original SSTable.

Solution¶

  1. Prevent automatic tombstones compactions by increasing the value of tombstone_compaction_interval to some big value (it’s integer value representing a time period in seconds).

For example this will change it to 4 days:

ALTER table <your table name> with compaction = { 'class' : 'SizeTieredCompactionStrategy', 'tombstone_compaction_interval' : 345600 };

Troubleshoot

PREVIOUS
Scylla Fails to Start - SSTable Corruption Problem
NEXT
CQL
ScyllaDB Open Source
  • 5.1
    • master
    • 5.2
    • 5.1
  • Getting Started
    • Install Scylla
      • ScyllaDB Web Installer for Linux
      • Scylla Unified Installer (relocatable executable)
      • Air-gapped Server Installation
      • What is in each RPM
      • Scylla Housekeeping and how to disable it
      • Scylla Developer Mode
      • Scylla Configuration Reference
    • Configure Scylla
    • ScyllaDB Requirements
      • System Requirements
      • OS Support by Platform and Version
      • Scylla in a Shared Environment
    • Migrate to ScyllaDB
      • Migration Process from Cassandra to Scylla
      • Scylla and Apache Cassandra Compatibility
      • Migration Tools Overview
    • Integration Solutions
      • Integrate Scylla with Spark
      • Integrate Scylla with KairosDB
      • Integrate Scylla with Presto
      • Integrate Scylla with Elasticsearch
      • Integrate Scylla with Kubernetes
      • Integrate Scylla with the JanusGraph Graph Data System
      • Integrate Scylla with DataDog
      • Integrate Scylla with Kafka
      • Integrate Scylla with IOTA Chronicle
      • Integrate Scylla with Spring
      • Shard-Aware Kafka Connector for Scylla
      • Install Scylla with Ansible
      • Integrate Scylla with Databricks
    • Tutorials
  • Scylla for Administrators
    • Administration Guide
    • Procedures
      • Cluster Management
      • Backup & Restore
      • Change Configuration
      • Maintenance
      • Best Practices
      • Benchmarking Scylla
      • Migrate from Cassandra to Scylla
      • Disable Housekeeping
    • Security
      • Scylla Security Checklist
      • Enable Authentication
      • Enable and Disable Authentication Without Downtime
      • Generate a cqlshrc File
      • Reset Authenticator Password
      • Enable Authorization
      • Grant Authorization CQL Reference
      • Role Based Access Control (RBAC)
      • Scylla Auditing Guide
      • Encryption: Data in Transit Client to Node
      • Encryption: Data in Transit Node to Node
      • Generating a self-signed Certificate Chain Using openssl
      • Encryption at Rest
      • LDAP Authentication
      • LDAP Authorization (Role Management)
    • Admin Tools
      • Nodetool Reference
      • CQLSh
      • REST
      • Tracing
      • Scylla SStable
      • Scylla Types
      • SSTableLoader
      • cassandra-stress
      • SSTabledump
      • SSTable2json
      • SSTable Index
      • Scylla Logs
      • Seastar Perftune
      • Virtual Tables
    • ScyllaDB Monitoring Stack
    • ScyllaDB Operator
    • ScyllaDB Manager
    • Upgrade Procedures
      • Scylla Enterprise
      • Scylla Open Source
      • Scylla Open Source to Scylla Enterprise
      • Scylla AMI
    • System Configuration
      • System Configuration Guide
      • scylla.yaml
      • Scylla Snitches
    • Benchmarking Scylla
  • Scylla for Developers
    • Learn To Use Scylla
      • Scylla University
      • Course catalog
      • Scylla Essentials
      • Basic Data Modeling
      • Advanced Data Modeling
      • MMS - Learn by Example
      • Care-Pet an IoT Use Case and Example
    • Scylla Alternator
    • Scylla Features
      • Scylla Open Source Features
      • Scylla Enterprise Features
    • Scylla Drivers
      • Scylla CQL Drivers
      • Scylla DynamoDB Drivers
  • CQL Reference
    • CQLSh: the CQL shell
    • Appendices
    • Compaction
    • Consistency Levels
    • Consistency Level Calculator
    • Data Definition
    • Data Manipulation
    • Data Types
    • Definitions
    • Global Secondary Indexes
    • Additional Information
    • Expiring Data with Time to Live (TTL)
    • Additional Information
    • Functions
    • JSON Support
    • Materialized Views
    • Non-Reserved CQL Keywords
    • Reserved CQL Keywords
    • ScyllaDB CQL Extensions
  • Scylla Architecture
    • Scylla Ring Architecture
    • Scylla Fault Tolerance
    • Consistency Level Console Demo
    • Scylla Anti-Entropy
      • Scylla Hinted Handoff
      • Scylla Read Repair
      • Scylla Repair
    • SSTable
      • Scylla SSTable - 2.x
      • ScyllaDB SSTable - 3.x
    • Compaction Strategies
    • Raft Consensus Algorithm in ScyllaDB
  • Troubleshooting Scylla
    • Errors and Support
      • Report a Scylla problem
      • Error Messages
      • Change Log Level
    • Scylla Startup
      • Ownership Problems
      • Scylla will not Start
      • Scylla Python Script broken
    • Cluster and Node
      • Failed Decommission Problem
      • Cluster Timeouts
      • Node Joined With No Data
      • SocketTimeoutException
      • NullPointerException
    • Data Modeling
      • Scylla Large Partitions Table
      • Scylla Large Rows and Cells Table
      • Large Partitions Hunting
    • Data Storage and SSTables
      • Space Utilization Increasing
      • Disk Space is not Reclaimed
      • SSTable Corruption Problem
      • Pointless Compactions
      • Limiting Compaction
    • CQL
      • Time Range Query Fails
      • COPY FROM Fails
      • CQL Connection Table
      • Reverse queries fail
    • Scylla Monitor and Manager
      • Manager and Monitoring integration
      • Manager lists healthy nodes as down
  • Knowledge Base
    • Upgrading from experimental CDC
    • Compaction
    • Counting all rows in a table is slow
    • CQL Query Does Not Display Entire Result Set
    • When CQLSh query returns partial results with followed by “More”
    • Run Scylla and supporting services as a custom user:group
    • Decoding Stack Traces
    • Snapshots and Disk Utilization
    • DPDK mode
    • Debug your database with Flame Graphs
    • How to Change gc_grace_seconds for a Table
    • Gossip in Scylla
    • Increase Permission Cache to Avoid Non-paged Queries
    • How does Scylla LWT Differ from Apache Cassandra ?
    • Map CPUs to Scylla Shards
    • Scylla Memory Usage
    • NTP Configuration for Scylla
    • Updating the Mode in perftune.yaml After a ScyllaDB Upgrade
    • POSIX networking for Scylla
    • Scylla consistency quiz for administrators
    • Recreate RAID devices
    • How to Safely Increase the Replication Factor
    • Scylla and Spark integration
    • Increase Scylla resource limits over systemd
    • Scylla Seed Nodes
    • How to Set up a Swap Space
    • Scylla Snapshots
    • Scylla payload sent duplicated static columns
    • Stopping a local repair
    • System Limits
    • How to flush old tombstones from a table
    • Time to Live (TTL) and Compaction
    • Scylla Nodes are Unresponsive
    • Update a Primary Key
    • Using the perf utility with Scylla
    • Configure Scylla Networking with Multiple NIC/IP Combinations
  • ScyllaDB University
  • Scylla FAQ
  • Contribute to ScyllaDB
  • Glossary
  • Alternator: DynamoDB API in Scylla
    • Getting Started With ScyllaDB Alternator
    • Scylla Alternator for DynamoDB users
  • Create an issue
  • Edit this page

On this page

  • There Are A Lot Of Single SSTable Compactions That Don’t Compact Anything
    • Phenomena
    • Problem
    • Solution
Logo
Docs Contact Us About Us
Mail List Icon Slack Icon Forum Icon
© 2023, ScyllaDB. All rights reserved.
Last updated on 31 Mar 2023.
Powered by Sphinx 4.3.2 & ScyllaDB Theme 1.4.2